Sometimes you want to treat yourself to favorite childhood dishes, especially when you are thousands of kilometers away from home. Whether it is ribs, potato and cheese pierogi, or hearty white borscht with crispy kielbasa, you can still find authentic Polish food in New York City. We have compiled the top 7 best Polish restaurants in New York. These spots offer the best of Polish cuisine, top-notch service, and cozy atmospheres that will transport you right back to Poland.
Content
1. Karczma
Stepping into one of the best Polish restaurants feels like entering a cozy farmhouse tucked away in the Polish countryside. The vibe is authentic, with waitstaff decked out in traditional attire. And the menu? It is packed with classic dishes like sausage, stuffed cabbage rolls, and savory pierogies. But be warned — the menu is extensive, so choosing can be tough. Our advice? Do not hold back. Try a bit of everything: a plate of three boiled or fried pierogi, Polish kielbasa, hearty hunter’s stew, or stuffed cabbage. And the best part? The prices will not break the bank — three filling dishes will only set you back 15-20 bucks. But it is not just about the food here. Karczma is not just a restaurant; it is a taste of home. With its traditional cuisine and Polish music, it is the perfect spot to unwind with a cold beer after a long day. The restaurant is open every day not only for indoor dining but also for takeout and delivery.
Address: 136 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
2. Christina's
If you are searching for ‘Polish food near me’, look at Christina’s in Greenpoint, which has been wowing locals and visitors alike with its mouth-watering Polish dishes for 30 years. Whether you stumble in for a quick bite or host a family gathering, this place has you covered. Forget about counting carbs here — this menu is all about hearty comfort food: steamed pierogi, spicy beef stew with tender meat and potatoes, ribs, flavorful goulash, and vibrant beet and cabbage salads. The atmosphere is cozy and traditional, with brick walls that make you feel like you are dining in an old Polish fortress tucked away in the woods. And the best part? Christina’s serves up homemade favorites at wallet-friendly prices: soups range from $7 to $9.5, pierogi are $13, Pork Schnitzel goes for $15, Vegetarian Lazanki is $14, and Beef Goulash with Potato Pierogi is $17.
Address: 853 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
3. Polka Dot
Located in the heart of Greenpoint, Brooklyn, Polka Dot is another best Polish restaurant offering a diverse array of Polish food near you. When it comes to finding better food prices in New York, it is nearly impossible to beat Polka Dot. Despite the unbeatable prices, their menu is packed with delicious offerings. From vegetarian options like stuffed cabbage and zucchini pancakes to hearty meat dishes like braised pork stew and chicken with mushrooms, they have got it all. Picture this: vegan pickle soup without gluten for just $5, and krokiet with meat for $4.5. Their commitment to low prices is something they take pride in, and they even offer discounts if you find a similar item priced lower elsewhere.
Address: 726 Manhattan Ave Brooklyn, NY 11222
4. Green’s Bakery
Looking to try some fantastic Polish pastries and desserts, like the traditional babka, even if you are far from Poland? It is doable. The destination is Brooklyn, Green’s Bakery. Here, they bake over a million babkas every year. The bakery was founded by Mrs. Green, renowned citywide for her baking skills. Her strudel even won the most prestigious award in the state. Later, her children inherited much of her culinary knowledge and opened a shop. Now, Green’s Bakery takes orders from around the world. Despite its popularity, their pastry prices are quite reasonable. A 24 oz Cinnamon or Chocolate Babka will set you back $10.49. Vegan options are just a dollar more. And if you are looking for something smaller, their 14 oz options are even cheaper at just $6.99.
Address: 65 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
5. Old Traditional Polish Cuisine
Old Traditional Polish Cuisine is no ordinary restaurant — it is a food truck that cruises around Manhattan, dishing out traditional Polish fare to anyone craving it. Their menu is a flavor explosion, featuring delights like Smokin' HOT Grilled Kielbasa, handmade pierogi stuffed with potato and cheese, and a hearty stew with a perfect blend of meat, sausages, and veggies, all cooked to perfection. Whether you are a veggie lover or a hardcore carnivore, they have got something for you. And the best part? The prices will not break the bank. A mix of pierogi varieties goes for $15 for a small portion or $17 for a large. The Lite Combo, including Grilled Kielbasa, 4 Potato & Cheese Pierogi, and Pickle Salad of the Day, comes with Grandma’s Bread and Polish Hot Mustard — all for the same price. You can catch Old Traditional Polish Cuisine not just on Manhattan’s streets, but you can also book them for private parties, weddings, corporate events, and even fashion shoots.
Address: 55 Old Slip, New York, NY 10004
6. Pyza
Located on Nassau Street in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, Pyza is a cozy family-style cafeteria-style restaurant. The food here tastes just like it does in Poland. Known for its authentic Polish cuisine, Pyza’s menu boasts a variety of soups, salads, pierogi, stews, potato pancakes, stuffed cabbage, sausages, and more. Low prices and huge portions are pleasantly surprising: the cutlets take up 3 ⁄ 4 of the plate, leaving a place for plenty of mashed potatoes and Eastern European pickles: beets, various types of cabbage, and cucumber salad. Whether you are dining solo or with a group, there is plenty of space for everyone. And if you are in a hurry, you can always grab your meal to go. Plus, Pyza is one of the Top 7 best Polish restaurants in New York available for events and delivery orders, too.
Address: 118 Nassau Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
7. Milk & Roses
Milk & Roses is a unique spot where you can enjoy American and modern Polish cuisine with a hint of Southern Italian influence. Everyone will find something to their taste here. And for dinner, their wine bar offers a rich selection of boutique wines, craft beers, and classic cocktails. What makes Milk & Roses truly unforgettable is its one-of-a-kind interior, giving off an antique vibe. It feels like stepping into an old library or the study of a medieval thinker, with walls lined with old books. Just a heads up: before heading to the restaurant, double-check that you have not forgotten your credit card. The prices match the ambiance perfectly: three lamb meatballs will set you back $21, pasta Pomodoro e Basilico — $22, baby pork back rib — $35, and for wine and cocktails, expect to pay between $15 and $17.
Address: 35 Box St, Brooklyn, NY 11222
